Sweet Treats
Want something sweet to treat yourself or someone special? We've got you covered! We are a small-batch bakery, and are happy to offer 6 of any of our sweet treats for same day pick up. If you are in need of a larger number of items, please give us 72 hours notice.
Cookies!
We have a selection of cookies available every day. You may order as many as you like 72 hours in advance. We also have smaller sizes available for events.
Chocolate Chip Cookies
$3.50/$36.00 per dozen
Does it get more classic than this? Made with extra brown sugar and the best quality chocolate chips
Snickerdoodles
$3.50/$36.00 per dozen
Just saying the word makes you happy! Our Snickerdoodles will bring you straight back to your childhood
Oatmeal Cranberry
$3.50/$36.00 per dozen
Ummmm, yes please!
Peanut Butter
$3.50/$36.00 per dozen
if You love peanut butter, these cookies are for you! We pack them with crunchy peanut butter for that classic taste.
Ginger
$3.50/$36.00 per dozen
Old fashioned ginger flavor! We add molasses to these classic cookies for a spicy, chewy bite. Just like grandma used to make!
Sandwich Cookies
$4.00/$40.00 per dozen
Little Debbie’s got nothin on us! From oatmeal cream, to chocolate cream and spice, they are deeeeelish!
Revolving Cookies (different every day!)
$3.50/$36.00 per dozen
Tuesday: Mexican Hot Chocolate
Wednesday: White Chocolate Coconut Mac Nut
Thursday: Lemon Crinkle
Friday: Nutty Chocolate Chip
Saturday: Baker’s Choice!
Bars!
Our selection of bars is bar-none! (See what I did there?) All can be ordered 72 hours in advance for larger quantities. We will gladly cut them in half or quarters for events.
Triple Chocolate Brownies
$3.50/$36.00 per dozen
Yes, we said TRIPLE CHOCOLATE! Dense and fudge, these are the real deal!
White Chocolate Butterscotch Blondies
$3.50/$36.00 per dozen
If our Triple Chocolate Brownies had an out of town cousin, this would be him.
Lemon Brownies
$3.50/$36.00 per dozen
Yes, you read that right…LEMON brownies! They are brownies in the way they are moist, chewy, and delicious, but full of real lemon flavor! We zest and squeeze actual lemons and add white chocolate chips to make them even more irresistible.
Coconut Joy
$4.00/$40.00 per dozen
Dark chocolate brownie on the bottom, moist, chewy coconutty macaroon on the top. The best of all worlds!
Revolving Bars (different every day!)
$3.50/$4.00 each $36.00/$40.00 per dozen
Tuesday: Chewy Nut Bar
Wednesday: Oat Bar
Thursday: Cheesecake Bar
Friday: Peanut Butter Brownie/Peanut Butter and Jelly Bar
Saturday: Baker’s Choice!
Cinnamon Donut Muffins
$.50 each
Seriously addictive. There is a reason we call them the gateway muffin. For .50 we dare you to buy only one!
Breakfast Items
Just starting your day, and want something yummy? Check out our daily breakfast goodies!
Scones
$3.50
Our delicious scones are made fresh every morning. We offer an assortment of flavors from Cranberry to Cherry Almond. Come check daily and see which one is your favorite, but be here early, they sell out quick!
Coffee Cake Muffins
$4.00
Baked fresh every morning, our Coffee Cake Muffins are chock full of delicious cinnamon and loaded with crunchy topping. A great accompaniment to your favorite morning brew.
Morning Muffin or Buckle
$4.00
The term "Buckle" is used to describe a muffin that has "buckled" in on itself due to the large amount of fresh fruit within. Our Muffins and Buckles certainly live up to that! Baked fresh every morning, we use fresh seasonal fruits and berries to make to MOST delicious muffins ever!
Loaf Slices and Whole Loaves
$3.50/$22.00
Our Morning Glory loaf is second to none. loaded with carrots, cranberries, apples, coconut, pecans, and pineapple, it is truly a morning GLORY! Other flavors include or famous Lemon Loaf, Banana Pecan, Mocha Loaf, and many more. Sold by the slice, and as whole loaves when available. They can always be ordered ahead, as well.
Savory Items
Breakfast Burritos
2 scrambled eggs, cheese, tater tots, and salsa, all wrapped up in a warm flour tortilla. Served daily until 1:00, or until we run out!
Classic No-Meat
$5.00
Our standard breakfast burrito
Bacon
$5.50
Standard burrito, add crispy bacon
Sausage
$5.50
Add pork breakfast sausage
Chorizo
$5.50
Add pork chorizo
Sandwiches
Made fresh daily on your choice of Buttermilk White or Wheat bread.
$6.00
We offer Tuna Salad, Turkey and Swiss, Ham and Swiss, or Egg Salad. Call or come by to see what we have available daily.
Soup
Made in house with all fresh ingredients.
Flavors change regularly, call ahead or come in to see what we have daily.
12 oz
$5.00
16 oz
$7.00
Quart
$12.00
Cakes and Pies
Standard 6” cakes
We offer 6” cakes for same day pick up. Please call for availability. Cakes may be held for 24 hours prior to pick up. We are happy to add a message or fresh flowers to our 6” cakes upon request. Prices start at $40.00
Standard Flavors
These flavors are available for no extra charge.
Classic Vanilla
Doesn't get more classic than this! Delicious vanilla cake with our Sweet Reba’s vanilla buttercream.
Life by Chocolate
Because chocolate is life! Rich chocolate cake filled with chocolate buttercream topped with a deep, dark chocolate ganache drip. Yum!
Carrot Cake
This is the best carrot cake you will ever eat. Seriously, we’re not kidding.
Custom Cakes
We require at least seven days notice for custom cake orders. Our schedule fills up quickly, and sometimes we are not able to fulfill custom order requests. We do our best to provide you with the highest quality cakes for your special occasions. 6” cake prices start at $50.00 for standard cake flavors. Specialty flavors are available for an additional $10.00.
Specialty Flavors
These flavors are available for a $10.00 charge.
Raspberry Lemonade
Our vanilla cake filled with raspberry preserves, house made lemon curd, and vanilla buttercream.
Blackberry Lavender Lemon
Vanilla cake filled with lavender blackberry jam, house made lemon curd, and vanilla buttercream.
Razzelberry
Vanilla cake filled with raspberry preserves, fresh raspberries, and vanilla butter.
Lemon
Your choice of vanilla or lemon cake filled with house made lemon curd, and your choice of vanilla or lemon buttercream.
Chocolate options
Our moist chocolate cake filled with your choice of chocolate buttercream, peanut butter mousse, or vanilla buttercream.
Pies!
Available all year, must be ordered 7 days in advance. All fruit pies are crumble top. Subject to scheduling availability.
Key Lime Pie
$18.00
Sweet, tart, creamy and deeeee-licious! Made with a traditional graham cracker crust, and served with vanilla whipped cream.
Dutch Apple pie
$25.00
Flakey crust, crisp, tart apples, and plenty of brown sugar. You can add salted caramel sauce on the side for $5.00.
Pecan Pie
$25.00
Pecans, pecans, and more pecans! We load it full of pecans!
Lemon Meringue Pie
$25.00
We squeeze actual
lemons to make this sweet, tart classic. Topped with a toasted Swiss meringue, it is literally heavin in a pie tin.
Pumpkin Pie (available October through January)
$18.00
A true classic, we keep it simple. Lots of warm spices, real pumpkin, and flakey crust. Boom, done!
Seasonal Fruit Pies
$25.00
Whatever fruit is in season, we can make a pie out of it! Peach, strawberry, rhubarb, or anything else you can grow or pick, we’ll put it in a pie!
Our Story
Our Story
Sweet Reba’s began in childhood with a grandmother who was happy to share the joy of cooking and baking. Through the years, Reba had the good fortune to be able to learn from local legends baking for the Nepenthe Sign Parties. Reba went on to earn high praise from judge, Ron Ben Israel on Food Network’s Cake Wars, and continues her pursuit of baking excellence.
In 2004 Reba created her first “custom cake” for her son’s 7th birthday. Since then, she has been building the business from her Carmel home where she lives with her three sons and fiancé, Michael who has become her partner in baking. Michael has a background in the kitchen arts as well as his Italian heritage and brings treasured family recipes to the shop.
At Sweet Reba’s we strive to offer our customers the highest quality baked goods, using only the freshest ingredients. We can fill any of your baking and custom cake needs from birth announcements to weddings, birthdays, and any other celebrations and life events. We count ourselves lucky to be able to share our love and passion for delicious food with you. Come on in and taste something sweet!
Contact Us
Better yet, see us in person!
We love our customers, so feel free to visit during normal business hours.
Hours
Today | Closed |